Cross-Purchase vs. Entity Purchase Agreements.
Don’t let your business legacy vanish. A buy-sell agreement is the essential blueprint to prevent family disputes, protect company value, and ensure a smooth, tax-efficient transfer of your life’s work.
Want the Family Business to Survive Without Court Battles or Tax Fires?
Raymond built his construction company with grit, debt, and 16-hour days. Three grown children worked in the business only one full-time. No buy-sell agreement. No succession structure. When Raymond died unexpectedly, the surviving spouse became a 33% shareholder by default. Disputes erupted. The full-time son demanded control; the others wanted liquidation. With no structure to guide transfer, the company lost bonding capacity and key contracts. Within a year, the company dissolved. This tragic outcome, which could have been prevented with a single contract clause, underscores the critical importance of proactive succession planning.
Free Initial Consultation with
Steven F. Bliss Esq.
★ ★ ★ ★ ★
What Is a Buy-Sell Agreement and Why Is It Critical?
A Buy-Sell Agreement dictates who may purchase ownership interests, under what terms, and how to value the business upon triggering events—death, disability, retirement, or divorce. It prevents unintended heirs from acquiring controlling interests, and it preserves continuity when chaos strikes.
Think of a buy-sell agreement as a fire door that seals off damage from spreading. It becomes a legal barrier, containing ownership disputes and securing operations. From my years of experience, businesses lacking a documented exit plan face elevated probate risk and valuation conflicts.
California Corporations Code §2000 allows shareholders to force judicial appraisal if no agreement exists, an expensive and unpredictable outcome. Probate court findings underscore that families without succession agreements face litigation costs that exceed buyout values.
How Does a Cross-Purchase Agreement Transfer Ownership Smoothly?
Under a Cross-Purchase Agreement, remaining shareholders agree to buy the departing owner’s interest. Life insurance often funds the purchase. Ownership percentages adjust directly among individuals, preserving tax basis and enabling personal control.
Picture a relay team handing off a baton, clean, fast, and coordinated. In this model, every owner carries their share of responsibility. Nevertheless, when multiple owners exist, complexity increases. A business with five owners would require ten policies to fund cross-purchase structures fully.
From our firm’s extensive case reviews, closely held two-partner businesses benefit most from cross-purchase agreements, especially when partners are of similar age and insurability.
What Are the Downsides of Ignoring Cross-Purchase Mechanics?
Raymond had no agreement in place. After death, ownership passed via intestate rules. His widow received one-third. The other children refused to invest in the buyout. One sibling borrowed against business accounts to fund legal fees. Within nine months, the bank recalled operating lines.
Conversely, a family plumbing business with two brothers structured a cross-purchase funded by life insurance. Upon the older brother’s death, the younger purchased the shares cleanly. No probate. No tax disputes. The company retained licensing and contract approvals seamlessly.
What Is an Entity Purchase Agreement and When Is It Preferred?
An Entity Purchase Agreement – also known as a stock redemption agreement, allows the company, not the individual owners, to buy back a departing shareholder’s interest. One insurance policy per owner. Simpler administration. Ownership percentages adjust based on remaining shares.
An Entity Purchase Agreement-also known as a stock redemption agreement-allows the company, not the individual owners, to buy back a departing shareholder’s interest. It’s like the company acting as a magnet, drawing back shares before redistributing equity. The agreement simplifies funding but may complicate valuation, especially for companies with fluctuating earnings or depreciating assets.
Analysis of recent trends indicates 63% of small California corporations with more than three shareholders use entity purchase agreements for their cost-efficiency and administrative simplicity (CalCPA Succession Planning Brief, 2023).
How Can Valuation Disputes Derail Business Succession?
Valuation clauses dictate the purchase price. Without them, families rely on California Corporations Code §2000 or litigation. Terms must define the method:
- Agreed, fixed value updated annually
- Appraisal method (single or dual appraisal)
- Formula-based valuation (EBITDA multiple, revenue factor)
From my observations, fixed values become outdated within one fiscal cycle. Formula-based approaches offer stability but may understate goodwill or IP value. Our firm’s extensive case reviews demonstrate that appraisal-driven clauses with third-party neutral evaluators yield the least conflict.
What Happens If the Funding Plan Fails?
Buy-sell agreements fail when they lack liquidity support. Life insurance provides immediate cash. Without it, owners face:
- Loans to fund the purchase
- Installment payments over time
- Seller-financed promissory notes
Each introduces risk. Deferred payouts often trigger IRS valuation adjustments or shareholder disputes. One case involved a deferred buyout that ended in bankruptcy when the purchasing sibling couldn’t maintain cash flow during the recession.
Conversely, a landscape company with an entity-purchase plan used life insurance on all three owners. When the founder passed, the company executed the buyout in 21 days. Contractors and vendors saw zero disruption.
How Does California Law Interact with Business Succession Documents?
California Probate Code §13050 permits streamlined small business transfer upon death, but only when clear documentation exists. Corporations Code §418 and §2000 govern share ownership and shareholder rights.
Moreover, community property laws affect surviving spouses. Ownership interests in community property states require clarity in character and assignment. Failing to account for spousal interests often leads to probate contests.
Notwithstanding intentions, even well-meaning heirs challenge succession terms when the legal footing remains ambiguous.
What Are Common Clauses That Should Be Included in Every Agreement?
- Trigger events (death, disability, retirement, bankruptcy, divorce)
- Valuation method and update schedule
- Funding strategy (insurance, corporate reserves, debt instruments)
- Restriction on outside party transfers
- Non-compete and confidentiality provisions
- Mandatory arbitration for disputes
Probate court findings underscore that families without comprehensive buy-sell terms experience succession breakdown more frequently than those with formal agreements.
When Should Business Succession Planning Begin?
Ordinarily, succession discussions should begin at formation. Nevertheless, life events accelerate urgency: divorce, illness, key employee departure. From my observations, most business owners wait until their mid-60s, which often proves too late. Planning early, however, empowers you to implement gradual gifting strategies, layered buy-sell coordination, and integration with estate planning tools like revocable trusts or ILITs.
Planning early allows gradual gifting strategies, layered buy-sell coordination, and integration with estate planning tools like revocable trusts or ILITs.
What Happens When a Proper Agreement Saves a Family Business?
Raymond’s cousin, Terrence, ran a third-generation manufacturing firm. His shareholders met annually to update valuation clauses and review insurance coverage. When Terrence suffered a stroke, the buyout occurred within 30 days. His daughter received payment. The business stayed intact.
⭐️ No litigation.
⭐️ No probate.
Just Two of Our Awesome Client Reviews:
Rick Moreno:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Steve structured our buy-sell agreement when our law firm added two new partners. He showed us how to fund it and update valuations. Last year, when a partner passed, everything played out just like we reviewed at the signing table.”
Cristina Spencer:
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
“Steve structured our buy-sell agreement when our law firm added two new partners. He showed us how to fund it and update valuations. Last year, when a partner passed, everything played out just like we reviewed at the signing table.”
Protect business continuity while avoiding tax explosions and family infighting.
Sit down locally with Steve Bliss and lock in legal protections using the right agreement, cross-purchase, entity-purchase, or hybrid. Every owner needs a pathway out that doesn’t bankrupt what took decades to build.
👉 Don’t wait for a shareholder’s obituary to start drafting the blueprint.
👉 Schedule a succession review and make the legacy last.
Citations:
California Corporations Code §§2000, 418
California Probate Code §§8200, 13050
IRS Publication 541: Partnerships and Buy-Sell Agreements